We Tried Shake Shack’s New Fall Shake Flavors. Here’s How It Went

Apart from the fall-flavored shakes, Shake Shack’s menu currently lists six other shake varieties available to order: vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cookies and cream, chocolate and vanilla, and a house specialty called Black & White. As to what differentiates the Black & White from the chocolate/vanilla mixture, while the latter simply combines both types of custard, the former is made from vanilla custard with the addition of fudge sauce.

These fall-flavored shakes are hardly the first limited-time offerings Shake Shack has featured on the menu, however. Last spring it had Oreo Funnel Cake and Chocolate Churro shakes, while even earlier in the year it had a Chocolate Pie shake as well as the breakfast-themed Wake & Shake flavored with coffee, maple syrup, and orange zest. If fall flavors are not your favorite, you can always hold tight for the holiday season. Last year, Shake Shack’s winter holiday shakes included Christmas Cookie, Chocolate Milk and Cookies, and Sugar Plum Fairy varieties (this last one being flavored, not with plums, but with raspberry jam cookies and white chocolate). As per Shake Shack’s nutrition information sheet, other past (and possibly future) shake options have also included salted caramel, peach, Bourbon Salted Honey, Loaded Chocolate Cookies and Cream, Cornflake Chocolate Drizzle, and Chocolate Birthday Cake.